Lifetime Planning

Patricia Barrett CFP CDFA

832-858-0099

  • About Us
    • Getting Started
    • Summary of Divorce Services
    • Frequently Asked Questions About Divorce Financial Planning
    • Testimonials
  • Cooperative Mediation
    • Cooperative Divorce Mediation
    • How Texas Mediation Works
    • Divorce Mediation Articles
  • Divorce Financial Planning
    • Our Approach to Divorce Financial Planning
    • Community Property
    • Separate Property
    • Long Term Planning
    • Financial Planning Articles / Case Studies
  • Collaborative Divorce
    • Collaborative Divorce
    • How Collaborative Divorce Works
    • How We Help
    • Collaborative Divorce Articles
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Blog / Unraveling commingled marital assets in a divorce

Unraveling commingled marital assets in a divorce

August 28, 2019 By Patricia Barrett

Often, couples who decide to divorce after many years of marriage discover their “separate property” and “community property” has become “commingled.” In other words, they don’t know how to determine where “separate property” and “community property” begins and ends with regard to their finances. This issue can be very important in a divorce because “separate property” will be completely free of consideration when dividing marital assets, and will not be considered in a final settlement of the marital estate.

Most believe there is no way to figure it all out, especially if the marriage spans many years. However, “separate property” can be sorted out from “community property” if there is a paper trail or other records that can be brought into play. It is called “tracing,” and can be effectively done by a financial expert, such as myself, or a forensic accountant, if necessary. This challenge is more common that most people realize, but it not insurmountable,if monthly statements are available from financial institutions. (Thanks to today’s digital technology and online banking, most of us can access and store financial statements indefinitely.) By reviewing these files, we can trace the account and find an ironclad separate property amount.

Over the years, married individuals may have received gifts of cash, valuables, collectibles, vehicles, real estate, etc. from their spouse, family members or friends. This is considered separate property. Or, one spouse may have inherited cash, real estate, stocks and bonds, jewelry, valuables or other property. This is also considered separate property. In addition, if one spouse is in an automobile accident, for example, and sues the other driver’s insurance company, and gets a settlementor judgement, this is also considered separate property. 

One of my clients had received cash gifts from her mom throughout a 35-year marriage. Her husband’s divorce attorney claimed that the account was community property because of commingling, even though she had the account long before marriage. When her mom died, she then inherited more assets. The inherited funds were readily identified as separate. But what about the annual gifts? Yes, they were “separate property.” But the income on those accounts, all invested in mutual funds, was “community.” AND because these accounts were all invested in mutual funds, the dividends were reinvested.  So, community shares were purchased with dividends and the capital gains (meaning appreciation on the shares) was commingled between the community and the separate estates. By using “line-by-line” tracing of financial institution records over the years, and the “community out first” rule, I was able to clearly define her separate interest. The “community out first rule” means that because the couple pulled funds from the account over the years in order to support themselves due to the husband’s underemployment, “community” funds were already distributed over and over again. In effect, the “community” part of the account was spent, while preserving the “separate.”  

If you are facing divorce, and believe you may have commingled “separate property” with “community property” over the years, you may want to engage a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, like myself, to help you trace these funds and make a determination before you begin the divorce process. Proving this can have a significant impact on your final settlement.

Tracing to Prove Your Separate Property

Filed Under: Blog, Financial Planning Tagged With: certified divorce financial analyst, divorce financial analyst, divorce financial planner, divorce financial planning, separate property, tracing assets in a divorce

Contact Us

Call Patricia for a
Free Consultation
832-858-0099

From Our Blog

If facing divorce in the New Year, take time now to prepare

If you are considering divorce in 2017, you are probably dreading the approaching holidays. Let’s face it, no one wants to acknowledge marital discord when the theme is “joy” and “good cheer.” As … [Read More...]

Lifetime Planning, LLC

Phone: 832-858-0099

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Areas Served:

Cities

The Woodlands
Alvin
Baytown
Clear Lake
Conroe
Cypress
Dayton
Downtown Houston
Fairfax
Fort Bend
Friendswood
Galveston
Hockley
Houston Heights
Humble
Jersey Village
Katy
Kemah
Kingwood
La Marque
League City
Magnolia
Memorial
Midtown
Missouri City
Montrose
Pasadena
Pearland
River Oaks
Shenandoah
Sienna Plantation
South Houston
Spring Valley
Spring
Sugar Land
Texas City
Tomball
Victoria
West University
Also serving all Texas cities working by email, phone, and fax.

Counties:

Harris
Montgomery
Liberty
Chambers
Galveston
Brazoria
Fort Bend
Waller

Disclaimer

Information provided in this website is not meant to be construed as legal advice and does not necessarily predict decisions that will eventually be made by a court of law. It is strongly recommended that you consult competent legal advice if your divorce includes children or property issues.

Copyright © 2023 Patricia Barrett CFP CDFA · All Rights Reserved

· · ·

Log in